Hacker News Reader

Comment by djaouen | Hacker News Reader

AI does have some legitimate uses (i.e., Grammarly and GitHub Copilot). It’s just when people say they are going to replace a whole operating system with AI that they are full of shit lol

View on HN

Like the article asks, what is the 1 trillion dollar problem gen-AI solves? Sure there are use cases - but the point is that the potential value doesn't remotely line up with the investments being made.

World military spending is estimated at over $2 tn per year. Ongoing Russia's invasion in Ukraine shows that a hypothetical UAV with fully autonomous capabilities (because every known frequency is soon jammed) will meet enormous demand.

GenAI won't help with autonomous systems.

My assumption is that only part of those $1 tn will go specifically into generative applications. The Goldman Sachs' paper in most instances mentions AI in general.

But one can also argue that actively seeking and choosing targets is a generative task, given a proper encoding of a battlefield situation and current mission.

Except that in spite of enormous investments and engineering efforts we still have problems with fully autonomous vehicles and it's unclear it would really happen anytime soon, and here the classification problem is whether you're going to bomb an enemy or your own people. I'm not saying it's not gonna happen but it's terribly hard and 80% accuracy can wreak havoc on innocent people.

Russian air force has already destroyed numerous civilian buildings, in many cases killing dozens of people far behind the frontlines[0]. In at least one case, when 59 people attending a soldier's funeral were killed, there are "reasonable grounds to believe that the reception was the intended target of an attack, using a precision weapon"[1]. I think it shows that the military will be happy with much lower quality of classification than e.g. acceptable for driving in downtown San Francisco.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Attacks_on_civilians_in_the_Ru... [1] https://www.ohchr.org/en/documents/country-reports/attack-fu...

— Hey ChatUAV, please bomb enemy’s military base

— Certainly! bombs own civilian hospital

— No, the hell are you doing…

— You are right. I apologise for the oversight.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com