Hacker News Reader

Well-researched, comprehensive, well-written.

While I don't agree with the ordering, every western I can think of that I consider great seems to be on the list. Bravo!

More importantly, there are many westerns on the list that I haven't seen yet.

Thank you for sharing this on HN!

The list is excellent; I found some I did not know or have seen.

I always hated westerns, until I saw the outlaw Josey Wales, and later Unforgiven. The rest were just so formulaic and juvenile (especially the early Clint Eastwood spaghetti westerns).

Treasure of the Sierra Madre was good, though. The only bogart movie I ever liked.

Their #2 is my #1. What about you?

Greatest Westerns of All Time