What do HN people tend to run that doesn't give them issues? I'd especially be interested in routers that have good IPv6 support (maybe impossible but still.)
What do HN people tend to run that doesn't give them issues? I'd especially be interested in routers that have good IPv6 support (maybe impossible but still.)
I have it installed on an HP EliteDesk 800G2 SFF that my office was going to throw away. It has an i5-6500, 32 GB RAM, two Samsung 840 EVO SSDs and a 2x10Gb Mellanox card.
Before the Mellanox, it had an intel 4x1Gb, i350 IIRC.
I've run the PC with the intel card connected to a power meter and it was pulling 14-15W while running OPNsense and HomeAssistant, both in dedicated VMs. Some of the dedicated routers may be better than that, but when you factor in the price of the unit, mine isn't too bad, despite the rise in electricity costs here in France.
I don't have any other 10 Gb/s machine to test its max performance, but it could run PF with NAT at 2.5 Gb/s without breaking a sweat.
I'm getting by with a cheap TP-Link for now, but I'm thinking of getting a mini-PC with two NICs and enough oomph to run virtual machines well, and then putting VyOS on a VM. I've always liked the ERPoE's CLI capabilities (which were also a fork of Vyatta). I could probably put much of my former ERPoE config into a VyOS system.
I then looked at their subscription pricing and realized that individuals are not their market, not at all. So, yeah, if I want to run VyOS, I have to put up with rolling releases. :(
https://blog.vyos.io/community-contributors-userbase-and-lts...
They used to have donation options, where in exchange for a regular donation you get LTS releases, (via Patreon and OpenCollective) but both have been decommissioned. I'm not a huge fan of how that was done and how hard it is to find up to date information on that.
Nightlies are pretty stable in my experience, and with the off-device backups, a full recovery will be relatively painless.
Your options are to use the nightlies (perfectly fine IMO), pay a lot for an enterprise LTS, or be a non-profit/education and get LTS for cheap/free.
https://forum.gl-inet.com/t/gl-inet-can-we-trust-them-becaus...
Curious to see HN folks take on them.
At least that's my experience with GL.iNet MT2500A (Brume 2). I happily use their older travel routers though.
That depends on the model.
Their hardware is simple to manage and excellent for the low-ish price though! E.g. the UDM-Pro which is a 10 Gbit capable router for €350, and the UCG-Ultra looks great for budget networks.
The two other options I can think of is ubiquity and mikrotik.
Maybe they don't care to fiddle with a command line, read up on dhcp servers, ipv6 router advertisements, pf configuration and what have you. In such a case, throwing opnsense on some machine, clicking around on three pages and calling it a day isn't that bad.
The experience is close enough to an off-the-shelf router (except for the installation part), all the while getting a much better security situation.
In both cases it is behind a firewall (and NAT, if applicable).
At some point they changed to doing everything via the 'cloud'. Obviously their customers didn't like that so they gradually backed down.
I want to upgrade my unifi AP so I ask on HN or other forums once in a while. Last answer I got was that you can disable the need for cloud but you still have to sign on somewhere once to be able to disable it.
So I repeat: are you absolutely sure you didn't need to give Ubiquity any info or go through their servers this time?
Because I'd love to get a new access point...
With their "Cloud Gateways" (e.g. UDM Pro, UDR, UX, UCG-Ultra) it used to be difficult if not impossible to get them into a usable state without signing into a UI account, but that is no longer the case since a few years ago.
There are some exceptions, if you wanna use their cameras you lose out on some features if you don't sign into the cloud to activate those, specifically facial recognition stuff.
I switched from consumer to Unifi just because of the better signal.
Unfortunately, even in just this thread there are very mixed answers. One yes you can (and a downvote that probably means the same thing), your 'maybe' and one 'i couldn't'.
And my current AP seems to still be fine...
I guess the 7 pro is the latest and most future proof?
I then factory reset the AP AC HD again, and set it up as a standalone AP using the Android app on a freshly reset Pixel 6 running the latest version of Graphene OS.
Both methods worked fine to setup the AP without any UI accounts involved.
This is available on all APs able to run the current version of the AP firmware, which is literally all the APs released since and including the AP AC Lite (which is from 2014 or thereabouts, they support their devices for a very long period).
7 Pro Max is the current top-end model.
I highly recommend setting up a controller for managing the AP though, even if you don't keep it running 24/7 (you can simply start it on any PC whenever you want to make configuration changes), as when they're in standalone mode a lot of the cool features don't work, you only get one SSID (per radio) and no roaming support for example, whereas when managed by the controller you can have up to 8 SSIDs per radio on the latest APs, you can access telemetry, setup roaming, etc.
I missed the controller... had an old version on an old desktop then downloaded the latest on new machines and it insisted on an UI account back then.
Unifi devices are still pretty good since I haven't needed the controller in years. This new one says I have an AP AC v2.
In this case Unifi is going to make some more money off me next week since i want to try positioning the AP somewhere else (new wire, holes etc).
I do swear there were older versions of the controller (newer than my AP) where I couldn't figure out how to run it without the UI account.
> I don't setup controllers that often
I've only done it twice; once when I installed the AP the first time, and once when I retired the machine with the controller so I needed to install it on a new desktop. Second time is the one where I failed by refusing to make an UI account.