On the other hand, extended attributes and other filesystem-specific features could be problematic if you want to share files with other operating systems. If I copy a file to a FAT32 formatted SDCard, I need to worry about what might not copy over.
On the other hand, extended attributes and other filesystem-specific features could be problematic if you want to share files with other operating systems. If I copy a file to a FAT32 formatted SDCard, I need to worry about what might not copy over.
the other problem is that the filesystem/ desktop environment closely entangles 2 concepts that imho should've been more orthogonal. - data storage+indexing for apps (a common unified KV store would've been more general abstraction that can be used to build upon other kind of abstractions, would be nice if yo could define your own indexing instead of what's done with folders) - data/information access for users in the "desktop environment"
So, something like the Windows Registry?
I really, really hate this design.
what I had in my was just idle thoughts about providing disentangled primitives that could be used to build other things on.
for example the primary key for accessing a file/object could be (computer_id?, storage_id or partition_id , object_id/inode) + ways to define different kind of indexes based on you use cases.
instead of just making apps into silos you can have the things builts on top of these primitives be typed structured data objects + API/interface. have an Object explorer and programs can declare they they are able to display or manipulate custom data Type X. you can then have GUI be composable the same way the pipe operator work in the cli.
you can define a regular filesystem on top of these primitives, a relational database, a tag system, or something new all together. if you don't want folders you would ca to deal with them.
the work on fushia OS seem to explore something along these lines (BlobFs + MinFs + Components). (https://fuchsia.dev/fuchsia-src/concepts/components/v2/intro...) Pharo/SmallTalk seem to also explore the ideas akin to this. (https://pharo.org/)
to be fair the current state of affairs is similar enough with file extensions + mime info if you squint hard enough and pretend that app and systems folders files don't exist but it's held with pinky promises.