Bay Area city orders scientists to stop controversial cloud brightening exp | Hacker News Reader

Bay Area city orders scientists to stop controversial cloud brightening exp

sfgate.com

For the curious, here's [1] an IPCC paper on the subject of this sort of climate engineering. It's among the more promising geoengineering approaches to counteracting global warming if carbon emissions continue, although there's still a lot of uncertainties about it.

It's generally believed that we're already doing this by "accident". Along with carbon emissions, humans have released aerosols that block sunlight from reaching the Earth's surface + increase cloud cover, and are believed to be counteracting climate change to a significant extent (not enough to stop it, but enough to slow it down). We're pretty sure this works, because big volcanic eruptions that emit a bunch of sulfur aerosols are known to cool the Earth down (c.f. the "Year Without A Summer" [2]), and accounting for aerosol reduction has long been part of climate models.

A natural experiment of sorts has been going on for the past couple of years that further suggests this might matter. In 2020, new regulations on sulfur emissions (which are a significant pollutant in addition to their climate effects) went into effect for shipping around the world. Aerosols went way down almost overnight, and ocean temperatures promptly spiked to new record levels. Here's [3] an article from last year, when ocean temperatures were beginning to separate from the historical record; this process has continued dramatically through to the present [4], with global sea surface temperatures at record levels for the entirety of 2024 so far - despite the fact that last year's El Nino (which leaves a large patch of the Pacific warm) is largely gone and a La Nina (which leaves a large portion of the Pacific cold) is replacing it.

[1] https://www.ipcc.ch/site/assets/uploads/2018/02/WG1AR5_Chapt...

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Year_Without_a_Summer

[3] https://www.science.org/content/article/changing-clouds-unfo...

[4] https://climatereanalyzer.org/clim/sst_daily/

For the visual learners, here's a cool (short) video from Hank Green about the subject

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dk8pwE3IByg

Nothing to do with the experiment:

scientists were ordered to halt the experiment because it violated Alameda's lease with the USS Hornet, the aircraft carrier from which researchers were spraying saltwater into the air

Here is an article criticizing the stoppage:

'Marine Cloud Brightening Geoengineering Experiment Halted. Why do environmentalist ideologues oppose research on a possible emergency backup system to cool the climate?' https://reason.com/2024/05/15/marine-cloud-brightening-geoen...

Original (too long) Title: Bay Area city orders scientists to stop controversial cloud brightening experiment

Adding the most potent greenhouse gas tot he atmosphere in hopes of reversing greenhouse warming? Seems contradictory.

Um, sea salt is not a greenhouse gas. This is a U. Washington research project. They're proposing to protect the Great Barrier Reef by spraying mist above it like a thin umbrella. https://atmos.uw.edu/faculty-and-research/marine-cloud-brigh... -- IIRC the Alameda health department has a problem with releasing breathable particulates in a populated area.

Dihydrogen monoxide. Also one of the most common lethal chemicals.

Try putting hard water into an ultrasonic humidifier…

It matters what’s in evaporated water!

Reply on news.ycombinator.com