Hacker News Reader

Comment by ubutler | Hacker News Reader

Also, I’m not too sure that saying ‘ok’ is to ‘affirm or to express agreement’. Sometimes it can be used to simply acknowledge that someone has said something, such as when you say ‘ok sure’ or ‘ok but’.

And if I am wrong, and it does mean to affirm, then doesn’t that by necessity mean that it involves ‘offering an opinion’? Affirmation and/or agreement is not neutral.

View on HN

It's used in different contexts, including the original meaning of "all correct", which is apparently offering an opinion.

Almost sounds more like a statement of fact checking than of offering an opinion (unless said by the first person, as was the case during the very first usage, in a bizarre "I am right" manner).

I think a mumbled uh hu is about the best we have for this.

That also can be used in the affirmative: "Wanna get food?" "Uh huh."

"Understood", or "got it" expresses acknowledgement without agreement.

I've long thought that we need to create a new (short) word that exists solely so you can communicate that you got the message, but not indicate any position on it. Something like AROM (acknowledging receipt of message).

Of course, good luck keeping it in that semantic space even if you got it off the ground

I and many people I have worked with (all engineers, swes, etc) have been comfortable with using "Ack" (acknowledged) for this purpose. Sometimes we get funny responses when others aren't familiar with the intended meaning.

Another word you can use for this purpose is "copy."

'Got it'?

Whatever.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com