Kinect is dead. Long live the Leap Motion | Hacker News Reader

Kinect is dead. Long live the Leap Motion

live.leapmotion.com

10 pointsnicolas55ar7 comments

The title "Kinect is dead. Long live the Leap Motion" is obviously a linkbait, however I found the linked video promising. Controlling a computer simply by waving your hand without even touching the screen can, potentially, be used in a large set of applications.

Kinect is not dead and Leap Motion will live whenever it will be available.

I really want to see a demo of typing or some precise gestures.

Why would you use this for typing? This seems more like a mouse replacement than a keyboard replacement. Still, if you watch the demo closely, they show 1 cm level precision, which is damn good for "in the air" gesture recognition.

You can design an interface for just about any reasonable level of precision, but this appears to be a good match for the type of touch interfaces we're already seeing in iOS, Android, and Metro. Metro with a mouse kind of sucks, if I'm being honest. Metro with something like this would feel a lot more like direct manipulation, which is what touch UI delivers.

different use cases. Leap motion is for (extreme) short distance manipulation, which probably gives it the higher resolution, while Kinect is for mid-distance manipulation, which works well for games. I wonder though why would one opt for Leap motion and not buy a real touch screen if he needs to be that close to the screen anyway.

> I wonder though why would one opt for Leap motion and not buy a real touch screen if he needs to be that close to the screen anyway.

A couple of reasons that came to mind:

1) Smudges! I tolerate them on my touch devices, but they really annoy me. Gesture-based manipulation takes you three-quarters of the way to touch UI without the actual touching.

2) Gestures detection can occur in a plane that is different than the screen surface. A big reason we don't all use touch screens on our desks is because of the "gorilla arms" problem. Any interface that requires you to extend your arms to shoulder height must be limited to infrequent use because of fatigue. With a remote sensor like this, you wouldn't have to reach all the way to your screen.

You can see the benefits of this with a simple exercise. Reach forward at chest height to the point that your hand just barely passes the front edge of your keyboard and hold it for a 10 count. Now do the same exercise, but reach all the way to your screen. Hold that for a 10 count and the difference will become clear.

So many negative comments, I thought the video was amazing.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com