Hacker News Reader

Comment by BoxFour | Hacker News Reader

Several trends exist already actually that might qualify as "temperance" movements.

In mainstream culture, it appears that Generation Z consumes less alcohol compared to earlier generations (although they might be substituting it with other intoxicants).

More niche but still present are the peculiar trends associated with right-wing groups, 'nofap' and similar movements.

If you're referring specifically to a movement involving spending money, I agree and anticipate that emerging as well, probably merging with one of the above two.

View on HN

To add to your analysis: young women are much less "sex-positive" than the millennial generation, are more anti-porn, wearing less revealing clothing, and tend to be particularly critical of age-gap relationships (often throwing around accusations of grooming).

Jesus christ. Even nofap is being called a right wing movement now? Is this like when the media was associating fitness with the right wing and was calling gyms neo-Nazi recruiting centers? How degenerate do we have to become in order to claim our liberal creds under this bizarre zeitgeist?

Self improvement is more likely to be demonized by "left wing" people and promoted by "right wing" people in my experience.

I've never seen any suggestion in scientific literature that "nofap" is beneficial or healthy in any way that could be considered self-improvement, though I'm open to the idea.

Too much of anything is unhealthy. From what I've seen of that community it's basically guys who are addicted to porn and masturbation, they do it compulsively, potentially for multiple hours every day, instead of doing other things. If they change that habit they'll almost certainly benefit.

Yes, certainly, that seems to be the case now, even if it wasn't initially.

A very stupid analysis supports that idea: Looking at subreddit overlap with r/nofap reveals many right-wing adjacent subreddits in the top 10: MGTOW and asktrp (ask the red pill).

I think those were meant to be 3 separate examples - so not related to right wing.

I definitely think that today's nofap and other similarly dubious "bodily control" temperance movements are predominantly associated with those who hold right-wing views.

It's not to suggest that all forms of temperance are affiliated with the right-wing—many aren't, and some have even been noted in sibling comments.

https://www.rollingstone.com/culture/culture-features/coomer...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com