Hacker News Reader

In python when I try a new gpu accelerated array library, to write norm_arr = arr / lib.sqrt( lib.sum( arr*2, axis=-1, keepdims=True) , I have to read documentation for sum to see whther they use axis or dim in sum.

In javascript, to write the same thing I need to read documentation for a sum function, a broadcasted division function, a multiply function. I can probably assume that the sqrt function behaves and is named as I would expect

View on HN

If each of those operators were implemented as functions then you'd have different names for different implementations in order to avoid confusion over what type of division or multiplication they were performing. It's more verbose but that's a good thing since it prevents you from making incorrect assumptions about what's going to happen when you do a * b.

Why can you make assumptions about operation overloads but not functions?

Because there is nothing to make assumptions about. In the example code, both multiplication and division have a scalar on one side, there's no possible ambiguity of behavior. But there is the eternal question of terminology: do you specify dimensions by "axis" or "dim" and does your API actually use both terms in different places?

(that's what I think the GP meant, anyway).

Reply on news.ycombinator.com