Hacker News Reader

"Are the immigrants to my country from (COUNTRY) more likely (on average) to commit [1] a crime than the general population" is a very different question than "Is every immigrant from (COUNTRY) dangerous"

The latter is bias, because if you meet a person you should judge them by their own merits, and not by the ethnic/social slides they belong to.

[1] Or rather, be sentenced for a crime, some we're talking about statistics.

View on HN

It's a factual question about a group of people. Pretending it has no answer unless that answer applies to every single individual in that group is dishonest. And it's not what the question is asking (although its vagueness makes me suspect it's designed to appear to be asking that).

In any case, a 'yes' answer is just as much biased as a 'no' answer, but of course only one of them is considered biased by the test makers.

It's not a coincidence that of the many questions on that site, not a single one is "Is {GROUP_X} more likely than {GROUP_Y} to commit {CRIME_Z}". All the questions are carefully phrased so that they can pretend there are no measurable statistical differences between human groups.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com