If even the European Commission cannot get GDPR right, then what hope do small/medium businesses have?
It would be similar to a federal law in the US that dictate that no information stored in the tax office, police databases or social security administration may be shared or stored outside the US. US citizens may expect that when dealing with the US government, information stored about them stays inside the US.
In the context of internal security and national sovereignty, it make sense to have dedicated regulation. It similar to how lawyers/doctors has more strict regulation regarding personal information that other professions.