Hacker News Reader

Comment by Sytten | Hacker News Reader

How dare them wanting to make money. Seriously this is fine, if you are not happy fork it and maintain it yourself. AFAIK this is the whole point of open core.

What you are asking here is that business to support code for free that reduces their revenue. Code is a liability most of the time not an asset.

View on HN

I think the problem is the terminology. People grew up when open source software was also free. Open core uses the same terminology, although products are only open and free in a limited way. I don’t want to assume intend, but many users are mislead that way.

I think the problem is entitlement more than terminology.

If someone builds a feature faster, better, and more open than the paid alternative and gives it away long before the enterprise version even announces the feature, where is the entitlement?

The expectation that the feature should be merged in.

Just because you created an amazing pull request that everyone wants merged in, doesn't mean the maintainer should or want to do so.

Expecting it to be merged of course!

If they think theyve built something better theyre always free to fork the original. If they dont want to put the legwork in and have expectations that somebody else should maintain their code anyway, they should fuck off.

A person writes code for a feature that is not merged into the project and you call them entitled?

The entitlement is from people that think the devs have an godly obligation to merge this PR.

We have had free source code for decades, it is also a reason why UNIX didn't die inside Bell Labs.

The difference is that older generations understand developers have bills to pay.

Its the combination of disappointment that it wasn't merged and that it took several months to get back on a significant contribution (whilst adding their own version into their enterprise offering in the meantime). Of course there's going to be some emotions, and rightfully so.

They just let the guy create the feature and it will be integrated to the EE.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com