Hacker News Reader

Comment by xcdzvyn | Hacker News Reader

This was downvoted but I think it's true. I find it way easier to throw something together in a raster editor than e.g. Inkscape.

I want to draw. With pixels. Not huge bezier curves.

View on HN

I took the time many years ago to learn how to effectively draw with bezier curves. It was not time well spent. A good tool in my tool belt for the moment, but it was very much a use it or lose it skill. I tried to do something recently and it was like starting from square one, so I just used raster. Unless someone is doing this stuff professionally everyday, or they are really into it as a hobby, it’s not worth it.

I assume this is simply a software problem that could be solved with a better UI, but who knows if that will ever be solved.

On the other hand the people doing this professionally everyday are producing mostly vector graphics, just in Illustrator rather than Inkscape. They still export as png or jpeg, the vector versions only go to print (in formats like eps or pdf, not svg)

I always preferred working in Illustrator over Photoshop back when I did more design work, but then I was also almost always targeting print.

I work with Illustrator on a daily basis. Drawing everything with the pen tool is about as effective as opening up a 300dpi canvas in Photoshop and placing every pixel by hand with the pencil tool. There’s a bunch of tools for creating and editing paths at a higher level than thinking about every control point, just as Photoshop has a bunch of tools for creating and editing huge numbers of pixels in very complex ways.

It is useful for me to know how to think about individual control points, but it is rare for me to need to do this.

Things have probably improved, and/or dedicated vector apps have better options I haven’t invested time it. Learning curves abound…

I did this in Photoshop so I could improve my selections and make them smooth. This was also back around 2006 if I had to guess. At the time, when I looked up what to do, all I found was learning how to use the control points, so that’s what I did.

What would be a keyword to look for to find the more modern way, if I’m not looking to go down a rabbit hole or learning all the possible options to find those bits?

I actually use Inkscape religiously for making diagrams or even UI mockups, an particularly in love with Bézier curves. To each their own!

Another fellow Bezier enthusiast here!

I fell down deep into the rabbit hole of Beziers in the Rhinoceros modelling app. There is something special about clean higher order curvature continuity across shapes. It's simply beautiful.

That said, I have big issues with learning any other tool. So much of the app interface learning was required to be able to freely draw... I really do see, why the bitmap simplicity wins over in "I just need to have it done; needs to be published by x" cases

Reply on news.ycombinator.com