Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by throwaway48r7r | Hacker News Reader

Full thread

throwaway48r7r

Personally, I will be boycotting Nintendo and will urge others to do the same.

View on HN

Nintendo is the worst, and your entire gaming experience will be better on Yuzu or Ryujinx.

Sad to see this happen to the Yuzu squad.

<loves playing Nintendo games> “Nintendo is the worst”

I bet you thought you got him. My mans just learned that you can like a game without liking the company that makes the game

I think their point is that you're not taking a principled stand by stealing. If it matters enough to you to "boycott" the company, walk the walk and don't play the games by any means.

There might not be copyright infringement involved, so "stealing" is an unnecessary assumption (on top of being a misleading term for copyright infringement). Since Nintendo isn't the only source for games that run on Nintendo consoles, Nintendo might not get money from the self-proclaimed boycotter. But since there's no guarantee that Nintendo won't get money from the self-proclaimed either, I can understand why people would view the following scenario as cognitively dissonant:

  A person only buys physical copies of non-Nintendo-made games which run on Nintendo devices from people reselling legally-distributed copies (legal in the US with the first-sale doctrine, which unfortunately doesn't apply to digital copies). The person plays those games by ripping the files and running them on third-party emulators. The person publicly states that they boycott Nintendo the company and that they play non-Nintendo-games made for Nintendo consoles. Resellers might or might not spend their money on more Nintendo games.

By the way, iamunr didn't claim to boycott Nintendo. Perhaps iamunr buys Nintendo games but plays them on emulators. throwaway48r7r didn't provide any information about whether they'll continue playing non-Nintendo-made games for Nintendo consoles.

Rather, multiple companies make games for one console. If you buy those games not made by Nintendo from sources other than Nintendo's shops then you can boycott Nintendo without boycotting non-Nintendo game developers.

I believe developers on consoles always pay the console manufacturer a fee per-copy, so not so much, but that's probably the way that pays Nintendo the least.

EDIT: Just remembered the second hand market. Carry on.

Nintendo is the worst, and your entire gaming experience will be better on Yuzu or Ryujinx.

Is it a boycott if you are still playing the games?

It's just an attempt at justifying their piracy, you see it any yuzu related discussion on reddit especially.

My biggest issue with it is how people almost act like they're entitled to their stealing.

I pay for all the games I play, sometimes going way out of my way to do so (obscure japaese studios who don't sell outside), but I will never pay a company that attacks my rights. I say that as an x-nintindo superfan who owned every generation and 100s of games up until the wii when I learned of nintendo's outright delusional takes on reality and there abuse and misuse of laws and the legal system.

You are free to also delude yourself and call it piracy and "stealing" all you want, but emulation and playing ripped games absolutely is - and will hopefully remain - your right.

(i buy used games and use yuzu to play them. fuck nintendo.)

"Your entire gaming experience will be better if you spend twice as much on new hardware than something which came out 7 years ago, and also forfeit a bunch of other switch features like motion controls and detachable joycons"

Reply on news.ycombinator.com