Obviously some approaches and systems work better than others and are more tolerant to some kinds of faults. Unfortunately, none of this gets away from the absurd, insulting, and grotesque reality that care has to rationed somehow.
Obviously some approaches and systems work better than others and are more tolerant to some kinds of faults. Unfortunately, none of this gets away from the absurd, insulting, and grotesque reality that care has to rationed somehow.
I suppose straight up denying healthcare based on class would be worse. But such a system would actually afford its customers the dignity of honesty.
I'm saying that rationing is inevitable and our thinking about health care systems needs to account for that.
I understand there are utopian arguments for healthcare, but where is the demand to respond to them?
I am in no way condemning the individual response to this I'm just earnestly curious where this impulse comes from.
The sky is the limit with what humans can do, but under late stage capitalism, it boils down to the preferences of those who control the system, and nothing more.
https://nymag.com/intelligencer/2022/03/how-asset-managers-h...
We already have a centrally planned economy, but it's only for the wealthy.
I don't think these are contradictory concepts, nor does this do much to justify the objectively atrocious method we currently use to ration healthcare. Every dime of profit could have gone to healthcare—that's not rationing, that's just unnecessary and easily preventable cruelty.
We can fix this. Essentially, every smoker, every alcoholic, and every obese human immediately goes to the back of the line.
No need for this convoluted bullshit of a system.
Secondly, you're inviting some really complex moral and political arguments. There have been worse ideas than linking healthcare to a political assessment of lifestyle, but I suspect it'd be up there in the same orbit as communism, genocide and slavery. It is hard to see it ending well once the politicians start to disagree on the healthiness of people's lifestyles.
I dunno, in some ghoulish sense it might be the next logical thing for the US to try. Why stop at merely bad ideas?
https://www.kff.org/faqs/faqs-health-insurance-marketplace-a...