Hacker News Reader

Comment by nyanpasu64 | Hacker News Reader

Laptops with soldered CPUs require replacing the entire mainboard when the CPU dies, while older socketed CPUs can be replaced for the cost of a new processor (as little as $10 on eBay for lower-spec CPU models, but prices rise exponentially as you get to higher-tier SKUs with more cores or clocks).

View on HN

That's just plain wrong socketed mobile CPUs are nearly as expensive as the motherboards with cpu. Even for older thinkpads like the t430 the CPUs are more expensive than just getting a "new" t430. Besides the price motherboards die more often than CPUs that's why you see horrendous prices on eBay for decent old gen motherboards. It's a problem in theory that gets brought up all the time and just isn't true in reality.

I don't want socketed CPUs I want all the innovation and advantage of an M3. I just want to get a chip and either replace it myself or get it done for 50-100$ in a repair shop.

Exactly. The problem isn't the advancement of technology. It's the rampant gatekeeping of manufacturers and both politicians as well as some of the user base defending it.

I can buy a decent desktop i5-3570K on eBay for $10, or two lower-tier laptop i5-3320M for $10 (my laptop came with a 3230M which ruins 100 MHz slower). I'm finding Core 2 Duo mobile CPUs for $12-24 (higher-tier CPUs may cost more, not sure what you're looking for).

And for more than 10 generations old processors that's a reasonable price.

Aren't motherboards substantially more expensive than CPUs? I tried looking for a replacement Haswell Dell Inspiron 15 3542 motherboard (almost as old) for someone with a broken laptop, and saw results in the range of $90.

Dude if you want hardware that as ancient you do you.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com