Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by sva_ | Hacker News Reader

Full thread

sva_

German couple in 1820 https://www.reddit.com/r/ChatGPT/comments/1avmpfo/ah_the_cla...

1943 German soldier https://www.reddit.com/r/ChatGPT/comments/1awtzf0/average_ge...

Pretty funny, but what do you expect.

View on HN

Scottish people in 1820 https://twitter.com/BasedTorba/status/1759949016320643566

British / American / German / Swedish women https://twitter.com/iamyesyouareno/status/175989313218585855...

"It’s often assumed that African people arrived in Scotland in the 18th century, or even later. But in fact Africans were resident in Scotland much earlier, and in the early 16th century they were high-status members of the royal retinue."

https://www.nts.org.uk/stories/africans-at-the-court-of-jame...

an article about a small number of royally-associated africans in soctland in the 16th century does not justify an image generating AI producing large numbers of black people in pictures of scottish people in the 16th century.

The Scotland link in the grandparent post is to a picture of 2 people, 1 white, 1 black. 1 is not large numbers.

Look, Gemini is clearly doing some weird stuff. But going all "look what crazy thing it did" for this specific image is bullshit. Maybe it's a misunderstanding of Scotland in specific and the prevalence of black people in history in general, in which case in needs to be gently corrected.

Or it's performative histrionics

The argument I think you're making is "0.0001% of scottish people in the 16th century were black, so it's not realistic to criticize google if it produces historical images of scottish people where >25% of the individuals are black".

If you take the totality of examples given (beyond the scottish one), it's clear there's nothing specific about scotland here, the problem is systemic, and centered around class and race specifically. It feels to me- consistent with what many others have expressed- that Google specifically is applying query rewrites or other mechanisms to generate diversity where it historically did not exist, with a specific intent. That's why they shut down image generation a day after launching.

Your second link was removed

This was posted: https://drive.usercontent.google.com/download?id=1jisgwOVMer...

So, the 3rd Reich was not the fault of "white men" that were supporting the "superior white race" but a bunch of asian women, black men, native american women. The only white man was injured.

This is between tragic and pathetic. This is what happens when one forces DEI.

The African Nazi was amusing.

Maybe it was drawing from the couple thousand North African troops that fought for the Wehrmacht: https://allthatsinteresting.com/free-arabian-legion

I knew that someone would find something like this, they're not wearing the traditional Nazi uniform like in the photo.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com