Hacker News Reader

Comment by parhamn | Hacker News Reader

> they solve the problem pretty well once you got past that initial burden of learning them.

Please do share how the canary `use` hook solves: remote data syncing, proper data sharing across the UI, real-time remote syncing, incremental updates, optimistic updates, realtime collaboration, offline only, etc

These are table stakes for good rich apps now. Now your answer is probably going to be to 'use other tools for this' and the lack of cohesion between those tools is what I'm saying is crappy glue. The atoms aren't good.

View on HN

I think your question is valid! React does have solutions for most of these, but remember that even in Canary, its job is just to sync state between renderer<->DOM events<->data fetching, not to replace your backend.

- Proper data sharing across the UI: Contexts

- Optimistic updates: `useOptimistic`

- Offline only: Can you clarify? React by default is offline only

- Remote syncing, realtime remote syncing, realtime collaboration: `useSyncExternalStore` with a subscribe function that connects to your backend

- Incremental updates: What do you want to update incrementally? You can render the site component for component as they are loaded with Server Components. Otherwise, I don't think React has anything built-in for that.

That’s… not react’s job?

React is all about efficiently taking state and rendering it.

We use mobx for managing state. We use Hasura for syncing. We use react for display. That works well for us and our requirements.

> React is all about efficiently taking state and rendering it.

You sure about that? https://github.com/facebook/react/blob/main/packages/react/s...

I’m searching for ReactFetch and not finding anything. My 10 years in React tell me that react isn’t a library focused on data fetching, maybe I’m missing something and I would happily discuss it if you point me towards some more information.

packages/react/src/ReactServer.js imports it.

I don’t know what reactsever is either. Was looking more for some documentation to show what it is and how it’s used.

That's just patching fetch for suspense stuff, and suspense is literally about rendering state.

Sure, not a pretty workaround, but nah react isn't trying to be in charge of fetching here.

I've never mentioned React, nor really alluded to it (though it is one piece of the complicated problem).

I didn’t quite understand what you meant by “canary `use` hook solves” but you’ll have to excuse me for assuming you were talking about react.

My mention of the use hook (which was first mentioned in a reply to me) was to point out how silly a response it is to offer a random react hook and as the solution to the complex problem I initially discussed. Do read the thread and my initial comment again.

Hasura + React is the dream. https://github.com/Vetd-Inc/vetd-app

react-query's useQuery hook makes the proper data sharing and optimistic updates a breeze.

react-query (or @tanstack/query as its now called) has a few things which make it a little awkward to use beyond very basic fetches:

1. No concept of normalization. Fetching a list of entity type vs fetching a detail of one of those entities means you end up fetching the same data twice since the cache is only per query, not entity. And good luck trying to mutate its cache yourself to force it to cache by entity.

2. No good way to get the data out of react-query and into, say, my mobx/redux store.

3. Its query cache is global, but the `select` cache is per component/subscriber.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com