Hacker News Reader

Comment by dpedu | Hacker News Reader

It's possible that is happening under the hood, but none of the feeds I'm subscribed to are on a URL clearly owned by apple.

View on HN

it's the list of feeds that is hosted by apple (think of it as a search engine for podcasts), not the actual feeds or media files.

This would only matter in any way if you think that listening to podcasts is primarily a hobby that people engage in for its own sake. If you think they listen to some podcasts and not other podcasts because they care what's in the podcasts, why would they care if Apple hosts a list of podcasts?

discoverability, if a friend talks to me about a podcast I could be interested in, i'd rather just have the name of the podcast than a full URL. Here i can just use any podcast app that integrates with Apple podcast service and type the name of the podcast i want to listen to.

Your question is the same as: "Why do you care if $YOUR_SEARCH_ENGINE (google, kaggle, duckduckgo) hosts a list of websites?"

You can already find the podcast by name using the normal internet method of searching for it. Where does Apple come into it?

The last search engine to host a list of websites was Yahoo!, and nobody did care.

sure, you can use google or a search engine, look in the results for the actual feeds url (vs just a website or something), and copy paste it in your podcast player. Or you can just search from it directly in your podcast app.

The UX on the latter side is clearly superior.

not to mention that unless the podcast has an official site, a Google search for the feed will turn up 10 different mirrors of the feed, without any clarity about which one's the canonical source.

in the past i've subscribed to a dead feed this way i think because the author changed who they syndicate through. i assume Apple's directory is maintained in a way that largely avoids this (simply by it being the canonical directory).

> You can already find the podcast by name using the normal internet method of searching for it.

You could, but I suspect most people search in their podcast app. Which is where apples directory comes in.

A lot of smaller podcasts don't have much web presence outside of their RSS feed, and often have pretty generic titles to boot.

Ah, my app doesn't have a directory of feeds. It requires that I add urls directly.

yes, but the app you used to find that feed most likely used Apple's directory to find it. Unless you went to each podcasts web page directly and picked the RSS feed directly from them.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com