Ask HN: How do you become an expert in a field, starting from scratch? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: How do you become an expert in a field, starting from scratch?

2 pointsChiff07 comments

I’m a CS student, but I’m also very interested in Neuroscience and biotechnology. It’s a field in which I’m not very well versed in, my knowledge currently consists of listening to Huberman Lab. How do I go from there to being an expert, or at least, knowing the fundamentals so that I can understand research papers I read? I know it takes time, but how do I maximise the amount of stuff I learn in that timeframe? Any advice about the topic would be appreciated. Cheers!

View on HN

I have a degree in neuroscience. 4 years of study at a top school was not even remotely enough to be considered an "expert". For that particular field, expect 10+ years of dedicated study and acquiring actual credentials, up to and including a Ph.D.

I don't think becoming an expert in neuroscience in your spare time is a realistic goal. On the other hand, learning enough to understand basic neuroscience research is feasible. Neuroanatomy would be a good place to start. Know all the brain structures, their function, and their interactions with other structures. Know what a neuron is composed of, learn the types of neurons, and the supporting cells/structures of the nervous system.

Chemistry is extremely important, including physical chemistry, organic chemistry, and biochemistry. From there, physics is useful (kinematics, electricity and magnetism). In fact certain brain processes can be modeled as electronic circuits. Math (Calculus, Differential Equations, and Linear Algebra) comes into play at times.

I listed these subjects out of order. For context, during my degree program, we spent the first 2 full years studying chemistry, biology, physics, and math exclusively before we even learned a single thing about the brain.

Neuroscience is a very multidisciplinary field, and the wide variety of approaches to neuroscience research reflects that.

Also be wary of "neuroscience" papers that are really just psychology papers. They tend to be light on math/chemistry, and heavy on behaviorial data.

I got interested in the field in high school after reading some books by Oliver Sacks and Marvin Minsky, two prominent former neuroscience and cognitive science researchers. You might like their books too, they tend to be more accessible to the layman.

Since you're a student, why don't you look into minoring in neuroscience?

Hey! Thanks for the response. I’ll look into it, but that’s a few years ahead, I’m only in sophmore year of undergrad. But yeah, I’ll first start with the fundamentals. Thanks again!

I have two cents. “Expert” can mean a few different things. On the one hand, it can mean expertise in the knowledge pertaining to the field. On the other hand, it can also mean becoming a part of a community of like-minded and like-interested people engaged in furthering that field and being practitioners of it. With that in mind, you might also try to get connected with other people interested in what you want to learn about, whether that’s as simple as participating in an online forum or local book club, or something more involved such as taking an academic class or joining a professional society.

Thanks for the advice. So basically, just get immersed into the world of the field as much as possible?

You may not want to jump in the deep end. But maybe take one step at a time in the directions of knowledge acquisition and community finding and you can evaluate your progress and satisfaction as you go. Best of luck!

Learn it like the experts. Historically.

Understand what the earliest principles were and how they evolved into today’s principles. Find books written by the early pioneers or those who can introduce you to them.

Enjoy the journey but if you’re looking for an easy way, there’s none.

Reading 1-3 hours a day will get you really far in five years, further than those with degrees. Couple your reading with 10-30 minutes of writing and reflection and you will be a master by no time. Share your favorite findings at the end of the week in a podcast and newsletter, and buddy, you will be having lunch with Andrew Huberman in a few years.

> Reading 1-3 hours a day will get you really far in five years, further than those with degrees. Couple your reading with 10-30 minutes of writing and reflection and you will be a master by no time. Share your favorite findings at the end of the week in a podcast and newsletter, and buddy, you will be having lunch with Andrew Huberman in a few years.

Hey sorry to be a downer, but this is not very good advice. I’m not sure what you think happens in a 4-year degree program, but it’s certainly more involved than “reading 1-3 hours a day and 10-30 minutes of reflection”. And discussing neuroscience with Andrew Huberman is a totally different goal from becoming an expert in the field. There are much easier ways to do the former.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com