I don't think this has any consequences for science.
The question is whether the language / metaphor was too extreme as to be defamation.
The question is whether the language / metaphor was too extreme as to be defamation.
It doesn't matter whether he wins, the damage is done and now his children believe it is wrong science... That's the damage...
Seems like there is a strong potential for a chilling effect on scientific enquiry if publishing scientific papers leads to this kind of political vilification.