Hacker News Reader

Comment by 0x457 | Hacker News Reader

Absolutely not. Even without App store iPhone was significantly better than Windows Mobile 5/6.

This is 5: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Mobile?useskin=vector#...

this is 6: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Windows_Mobile_6.0?useskin=vec...

Devices were much worse compared to even first gen iPhone. Ironically, it only for worse because the industry decided that using their shitty resistive touchscreen with UI even worse than previous models - menus had large buttons, but apps were built for stylus.

View on HN

I had an HTC TyTN II windows mobile 6 CE mobile phone. Basically same year as original iPhone. IE was rapidly abandoned and unusable. But with Gmail + activesynch it was like a blackberry with instant email. Opera mobile worked as well as modern browsers, probably better than iPhone. 3G. GPS. Load a multitude of apps self contained onto the huge SD card. It was a much more powerful capable device than an iPhone almost even up to today's standards. But it was clunky as hell and setting up the mobile internet was an insanely complicated process. I'm not suprised the iPhone won out.

I agree the devices were worse overall, however IE on Windows Mobile in 07 could render more websites well at the time including Flash support etc.

The browser’s UI was also worse thus the ambiguity.

Oh, I remember what flash on a mobile looked like in 07. In fact, I remember how taxing flash was on PC in 07. I also remember how vulnerable flash was.

Yeah, it could render more, but it was unusable because no one designed for mobile back then. IMO mobile world was sad until Apple came in.

Symbian was quite good, the only thing was the strange Symbian C++ dialect, which wasn't something sorted out by iPhone until the store finally came to be.

Symbian the OS was solid. Symbian the devices were mediocre. iPhone was much more polished and consumer friendly. Touch screen, size, weight, iOS, the browser, data -- it's hard to attributes iPhone's success to a single thing, but the overall package was head and shoulder above anything else.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com