Until you have to call 911 or equivalent and it doesn’t work
911 is a free call, no sim needed. So if that is your only concern a phone that you don't pay for may be fine.
A regular phone without a sim could work though
I've also been in a situation where if we did not have a sat phone in our group, someone very well may have died from heat stroke/way to many sunburns.
And now actually, I don’t even need service with satellite SOS.
What an absurd claim.