I live in a major city and the air would be better if everyone drove EVs, especially the trucks. Another major win is that renewables once installed (even if the materials are acquired from China) are energy produced locally which is a national security win.

Above that, I don't agree that EVs are reducing carbon by an order of magnitude given the way batteries are manufactured and the current mix of electricity generation. If you have a home charger and can have a second gas car for trips in rural areas (if you need that) then a pure EV can work. But a 100% transition to all EVs is unrealistic. It doesn't have to be all or nothing, and it becomes yet another wedge issue in American society that is going to cause a lot of social strife.