Hacker News Reader

Comment by IcePic | Hacker News Reader

If you try "ping" and "ping6" towards a multi-protocol host, you see both send 64 bytes each, so while v6 source and destination addresses take up lots of extra space, the v6 IP packets have less of the "this part could be useful for tcp" which means icmp pings can be of the same size, even though the two addresses eat up lots more bytes.

Not sure if the same goes for game UDP packets, but the optional header stuff in v6 IP packets means more of it goes to the useful parts of the payload and less to "the sum of all protocol bits and flags that is not used by all traffic".

View on HN

This is straight up wrong. An IPv4 ICMP echo request over ethernet uses a minimum of 42 bytes, the same request with IPv6 uses 62. The ethernet frame is 14 bytes and the ICMP echo is 8 bytes for both packets, the difference is that the IPv4 header uses 20 bytes where IPv6 uses 40.

Anecdotally, my ping to HN is consistently 166ms with either protocol. I doubt an extra 20 bytes is going to make any meaningful difference to latency, but I'll leave that for the game devs to find out.

There is nothing in the IPv4 header that is only useful for TCP, especially not in the parts removed from IPv6. Overall the IPv6 header gets rid of the 4 bytes of fields used for fragmentation, and 2 bytes used for the checksum. Fragmentation was never used for TCP in any sane implementation (as TCP can do fragmentation at the TCP layer), and the checksum were fully redundant for TCP. For UDP, the checksum used to be optional, but is now required. So, for an optimized implementation, the checksum removal isn't even a win for UDP, as it has just moved from the IP layer to the UDP layer.

So, we have added 24 bytes to the header because of the address difference, and removed 4 bytes from other places.

Now again, there are many differences between IPv4 and v6 that are much more relevant to latency than this extra header overhead. But it is a real overhead, there is no extra scope for payload. Your observation with ping is just wrong (most likely both versions are just padding the packets up to 64 bytes by default).

Reply on news.ycombinator.com