Hacker News Reader

Comment by subjectsigma | Hacker News Reader

I don’t give a single flying fuck about Bill Ackerman or his wife, they can burn in the fires of public opinion as well for all I care. The article is complaining that people are acting like victims when the political left made victimization a core tenet of identity politics. So maybe Bill Ackerman wouldn’t be acting in such an embarrassing manner if they hadn’t done that.

View on HN

Google "the lost cause", the "war on Christmas", "white flight"...

The right has played the victim card for decades. It's their core tenet.

Zionists have been using victimization as a core tenet to advance their agenda for decades. To say this started with the “political left” is simply not true.

It's third wave feminism, when the word emancipation was replaced by the very liberal and individualistic 'empowerment', and the liberal captation of postmarxism that created identity politics.

Saying 'the left created identity politics' is quite antinomic. Identity and individuality are clearly not core left wing values.

The left didn't make victimization a core tenet of identity politics. The left made power differences et abuse of power the core tenet of its politics - and the right caricaturize it as only "playing" the victim - the extreme version being the constant accusations of "crisis actors" lobbed by Alex Jones and co.

This is a gross deformation/strawman argumentation.

You called me out for strawmanning, used the most extreme and atypical person you could think of in your argument (Alex Jones) in a way that only tenuously makes sense, while simultaneously admitting that your example is extreme?

Maybe you should have replied with a third attempt at something coherent. Third times the charm, as they say

Alex Jones is not "the most extreme and atypical person" on the right, he is saying openly what the right thinks quietly: https://edition.cnn.com/2015/12/02/politics/donald-trump-pra... https://www.thedailybeast.com/donald-trump-jr-likes-conspira...

Reply on news.ycombinator.com