How does that work if you want to get an android phone or Samsung tablet or windows laptop at some point?
I’m terrified of losing access to all my stuff because of forced 2FA I never signed up for. I get that it’s more secure, but it can be secure to the point of having unrecoverable data. All it would take is someone carelessly deciding to get a new phone number. I have a friend who recently talked about wanting to get a new number with his new phone. I asked about 2FA and he seemed to have no knowledge of it and said he didn’t have anything like that. He kept his number, but if he didn’t, I could see him easily getting locked out of his Apple account (which he has), and his bank.
If you have recovery keys enabled, it’s a different story. Enabling screen clearly states that you can get locked out of your account without your recovery key. You can set up recovery accounts too, like those of your family members.
Then 1 yr later a hn thread will remind you to try to log into your google SSO and.. bam it works. And you still have no idea why ALL of your g servces (domains, email, gphone, etc) were disconnected a year ago.
1) I’ve never ever heard Apple lock someone out of their Apple ID. Maybe they are obligated to do it for law enforcement in US but even none of that. Meanwhile I’ve heard a ton of stories of Google locking people out of their accounts.
2) The convenience of using Safari, with 2FA and passkeys set via iCloud Keychain is too good to ignore. Literally 1 click (passkeys) or 2 clicks at most, authenticated with Face ID.
So I’m using this setup rn. You can set custom domains with your iCloud email too.
Always the tradeoff with Apple is choice and flexibility versus a seamless and pleasant user experience.