Show HN: I made a simple webapp to store your ideas. | Hacker News Reader

Show HN: I made a simple webapp to store your ideas.

ideab.in

14 pointsalex_g32 comments

It's dead simple. There's no fancy interface. Basic features are gone. That's all on purpose.

If you're like me, you're always writing down ideas on pieces of paper. My webapp is like that, but for the internet. Let me know if you find it useful.

Open articleView on HN

I'll go ahead and make some suggestions: like dlf said, it would be nice to be able to play with it before registering. Furthermore, you should allow the user to login with OpenID services such as Google or Facebook, anything you can do to reduce the time it takes for a user to get started.

You should add an easy way to edit the idea once it has been made. I frequently want to revise or add some resources that go along with an idea I may have.

It's a good start, but lacking some features that would prevent me from using it as a way to store my ideas primarily. I'd be interested in hearing about your progress, it's going to make for a great learning experience.

Thanks for the feedback! I chose to do a standard registration/login solely because it's my first php project- I want to learn how to handle forms and interact with databases.

As per the editing, it seems that is something I should really implement.

Alex, you should seriously consider making this an iPhone app. You're probably aware of how much more your peers are into mobile (instagram? tumblr? etc).

Additionally, I personally find the iPhone to be an amazing tool for ideation.

I'll consider it greatly as my next weekend project, although I have another project I'm working on ATM.

Too many ideas! :)

+1 for this. I'm a big fan of the pocket notebook. Having this as an iphone app is a natural extension of that idea.

Yeah I like storing my ideas on my phone too. I'm hardly ever near a computer when a lightbulb turns on! I use noted! http://itunes.apple.com/us/app/noted!/id504164257?ls=1&m... Follows the same keep it simple stuff but with better tracking than the iphone notes app.

Nice to see someone else enjoying my app!

I like the idea, but I don't see any reason why I should have to register before playing around with the app a bit. Let the user submit ideas and only require registration when they want to create their own private "bin".

The point of the app is to list your ideas. The user must register in order for the app to know which ideas belong to them.

And that's fine, assuming the user wants the app to know which ideas belong to them. From a UX standpoint, it's so much better to let the user kick the tires before requiring them to register.

Where would the idea be assigned if it doesn't know who the user is?

The idea is to fake the UX without storing anything permanently. Generate a temporary ID to store data to while the user is playing with the site. If they've added ideas they want to save permanently, overwrite the temporary ID with the new user ID. Storing the data only matters if they sign up. I'm a programming noob myself, but I think this should work. If I'm dead wrong, it should only take a couple minutes for me to be corrected ;-)

A little inspiration: splendidbacon.com/

Congrats on building something cool, btw!

EDIT: Go to account and look at the email address... it's randomly generated. Cool, huh?

I understand now... I don't think I would go that detailed as they have, though. I think I could achieve something similar with a demo made with Javascript on the landing page, no?

Yep. I think so.

Stripe does a great job at this. You should look at how they do this, its a very well executed implementation.

If I want to use Stripe, I have to sign up.

Added to a public feed?

Anonymous.

Hey, I built something similar to this a while ago. Find it at http://openthought.herokuapp.com/ Figured you might want to see it. I am also 16.

Nice! Our apps are definitely very similar (actually the same). I really like the prompt you are given when you want to delete an idea. It's very... bold.

What is it built with? How does Heroku work?

Didn't want people deleting their stuff accidentally. Built it with Rails. Click the "Github" link at the bottom to see the source. Heroku is really smooth (though expensive) Rails hosting. It's a little like magic.

"IdeaBin was designed and developed by Alex Greene, a 16 yr. old student at The Bronx High School of Science."

Keep up the good work, you've got some real talent for your age. Congratulations on releasing!

Thanks, I really appreciate it. However, I'd rather receive criticism as if my age were not there. If I changed the 16 to a '35', would you still say the same thing?

Send me an email ra3don92[at]gmail.com I've got some more in-depth criticism i'll pass along.

S/He'll be chasing the release dragon for years now. :|

Why would this differ to a normal note taking webapp, apart from the fact if you break into this database you are guaranteed only to see ideas?

You could use a note taking webapp. I use Evernote quote a bit. However, I find myself making notes of different ideas, different categories, when sometimes I just want to add an idea to a list, like you can with my webapp. For other simple not-taking webapps, if you use it for just writing down ideas, it's fine. However, I usually use note-taking webapps for.... taking notes. When I put an idea on the list, it's immediately an idea among "non-ideas". ideaBin is just for writing down your ideas.

If you have a demo on how it works it would be great

So as the administrator you can see everyone's ideas? Nice for you.

Technically yes. If I knew how to hide that I would. But seriously, I have enough ideas on my mind, I don't need yours.

Encryption maybe where the key would be something set by the user or something?

What like zerobin?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com