Hacker News Reader

Comment by nsns | Hacker News Reader

While beautifully executed, I fear that once the novelty wears off, such a mixed medium will be absorbed back into traditional animation. Why split the story into different frames if one frame can show it all?

View on HN

Maybe I'm a bit cynical, but to me this doesn't even sound as innovative.

To say it better, I don't think this will enhance the reader's experience, so maybe I see it more as eye candy (a well executed one, no doubt) than something really useful.

It sounds attractive to me, I like the idea of separate animated panels. I also think the idea of localized animation, to coin a phrase, could lead to some interesting presentation methods in more traditional books.

You could say the same for graphic novels in general. Why have pictures if text can suffice? Also take a look at Andrew Hussie's online graphic novel Homestuck. It features not only animated (in flash), but also interactive segments. These serve to give better representation to the action than simply explaining all the stuff that happens. Then he goes back to posting large blocks of text with only a static image on top, when exposition and clever word-play is in order.

Perhaps not innovative, but certainly a positive addition to the artistic expression of the medium. Similar to the addition to animation that "3D" CGI brought- they're still cartoons but now there's a new depth at the disposal of the artist.

A artistic medium doesn't need to enhance the reader's experience. It just has to deliver the artist's intent. New art forms do not have to be "better" than previous ones to work. They simply have to work. The usefulness of a medium is actually usually related to the logistics involved (how accessible is the medium, how easily can an artist procure and use this medium, etc etc) rather than anything else.

One designer can pull it off to make a graphic novel all by himself. But you need a team to make an animated movie.

Ahem.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voices_of_a_Distant_Star#Produc...

and

http://www.livingcels.com/

Reply on news.ycombinator.com