Hacker News Reader

Whether you have a copyright to a scan of a copyright-ineligible work isn’t a question that has been tested in court, as far as I know.

A copyright-ineligible work, however, can sometimes be protected by contract. Here, the restriction on the web page may be because the web site agreed with the scanning entity not to distribute a high-resolution version online.

View on HN

For the record, my guess is that there is no copyright in a scan of a copyright-ineligible work, because a scan is not a work of “authorship”. Unlike a photograph, which requires various authorial choices that reflect the photographer’s expressive intent, a scan is a mechanical and often completely automatic process.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com