Hacker News Reader

Comment by ducharmdev | Hacker News Reader

Re: your experience teaching synths in university, do you feel there is certain knowledge/concepts that are difficult for those self-teaching sound design?

I do the same "no presets rule", with most being the result of random experimentation and fiddling of parameters. This does a good job at "creating never before heard, totally out there sounds", but I imagine it's trickier the more specific your end goal is.

View on HN

I think the hardest part is getting the basics straight, and by that I mean things like understanding oscillation produces sound, amplitude influences the spund level while the speed of the oscillation influences the pitch. Understanding that by modulating pitch and amplitude you can already create a ton.

The biggest challenge for students in my experience is grasping all these obscure words and acronyms, with VCOs, LFOs, keytracking, Envelopes, ADSR, Triggers, Gates, CVs, oscillations, overtones, frequency graphs, filter cutoff points, resonance, ...

It is just a lot of concepts at once. Sometimes it can pay of to take a step back and limit one's arsenal and figure out how far you can get only using one or two of those.

Totally. I'm self-taught in this area and I feel like the biggest obstacle for self-study is that the basic concepts are often passed over too quickly (like simply the idea of using phase/the unit circle to represent oscillations, and how all that relates to frequency and period). I recently sat down and tried to make sure I really understood the mathematical modeling part of the whole business and it brings a lot of clarity when tackling more advanced topics. This is kind of true for self-studying any mathematical domain generally. It's easy to pass over the "entry-level" or foundational stuff quickly because on the surface it seems straightforward, but getting those fundamental ideas crystal clear and burned into your brain is absolutely crucial if you're going to comprehend anything that follows.

This is exactly what I think. The basics need to be understood. That doesn't necessarily mean they need to be understood first tho. People that learn synthesizers are first and foremost interested in creating cool sounds, so the best strategy to teach them the (for some: boring) basics, is IMO to repeatedly overwhelm them a little and then step back and explain things throughly.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com