Hacker News Reader

> Over 93% of 1st position domains are over a year old. This not only confirms the fact that Google favors older domains, but heavily stresses the importance of seeking aged domains for your projects if possible.

No, it doesn't. Correlation != Causality.

View on HN

you're absolutely right, that's why we included this disclaimer in the post:

Important Note: For this data, along with every other post in this series, we're by no means claiming that the key to ranking a site is simply to buy an old domain, nor are we claiming that a new domain can't be ranked. What we're trying to do is provide data that, when used holistically in your SEO campaigns, can give a competitive edge.

We're just trying to add to the list of best practices you can follow when trying to optimize your site for the search engines.

It's good that you included that disclaimer, but that line quoted above is simply false. The data you posted is interesting, but it does not confirm that Google favors old domains.

We're going to edit our post to clarify that and take a step back from our assertion because we do agree with you. Thanks for pointing this out guys.

EDIT: We've amended our post to clarify the point you guys have brought up. Thanks again for the feedback.

More likely older domains have simply acquired more backlinks.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com