Show HN: Pictorious - an app to participate in and create memes | Hacker News Reader

Show HN: Pictorious - an app to participate in and create memes

itunes.apple.com

18 pointsalbertchung15 comments

Pictorious is a game where you and your friends participate in and create memes. We're combining the fun game mechanics of social games (Draw Something, Words with Friends) with the ubiquitous activity of photo-sharing. Would love to hear the HN community's feedback on our little project!

I really like the concept of it, but I can't give feedback here on the app because I don't have an iPhone.

I think initially people will be excited to play contests against one another, but the issue I've dealt with in the past is: (a) someone starts winning massively and the contest becomes stale or (b) there's too many contests, and the community is spread out too thinly.

Thanks for the feedback... will definitely watch out for those 2 things going forward. Were the contests you were running for groups of friends or for the broader public? (we're experimenting with both)

Just tried to register. Pop up appeared:

"Password must be at least 6 characters long and can only contain numbers and letters."

I'm fine with a length limitation, but limiting the character-set - WTF? Stop this right now.

Hi mindhunter thanks for the feedback. I think we had put the same character limitation on the pw as we had on the username. Agree with you that shouldn't be the case and it will be changed in the next version. Welcome any other feedback if you have any.

So it's like that episode of South Park?

http://www.southparkstudios.com/clips/411094/the-newest-meme

Haha... this is great. I think I will use this in a presentation.

Neat idea. How do you plan to monetize?

Sell to facebook for a billion dollars?

Seriously, do you have any plans of how to make money? The server costs on this could get really high if it actually becomes popular. Then you have a hugely successful app that is actively losing you money.

Yep, we have thought through a number of different monetization strategies including sponsored challenges, private games / events, virtual goods and paid / ad-supported versions. The most important thing right now for us, though, is building a product that people love. With that in mind, we'd love any feedback you might have from that perspective.

I'm not sure I'm your target market as I'm not much for photo sharing type stuff. That being said I think the app looks great and was pretty interesting for the brief time I browsed it.

I'm just a bit annoyed at all the, "We'll get a few million users and then worry about how to make money." When I see a service I like that doesn't have any way of making money I'm scared it will go away. Note this isn't how the masses think, but it is how software devs think.

http://blog.pinboard.in/2011/12/don_t_be_a_free_user/

I agree, I think it's unfortunate when services get shut down post acquisition.

I also agree with you that all startups should have a clear path to monetization. I would assume that institutional investors would require as much before investing, but I think that would probably be assuming too much these days.

However, I don't think that all startups should "turn on" the monetization immediately. For those us trying to build two-sided platforms, we need to get one side of the platform on first. Typically this will be the users as brands and retailers are still very much focused on reach and are very slow to make decisions.

while i agree, in most cases I personally believe the monetization should start at the beginning. If it's going to be ad supported, adding that later will annoy users for example.

Some of the other things you mentioned I don't think would hinder growth at all. i.e. maybe in app purchase for the private section or sponsored challenges etc. It just seems to me too many good services get shut down because people don't think about how it is going to be profitable.

hmm.. this is actually pretty fun

Awesome!

Reply on news.ycombinator.com