Firefox Pirates Take Over Amazon | Hacker News Reader

Firefox Pirates Take Over Amazon

torrentfreak.com

25 pointsnoor42012 comments

"The timing of the ‘Pirates of the Amazon‘ launch could not have been more (un)fortunate. At the busiest time of the year for on- and offline retailers, this Firefox browser add-on offers users a download link to pirated copies of products that can normally be found in the Amazon online store."

I don't think that this is really such a tragedy. People who are going to try and download an illegal copy for free aren't going to be deterred by a lack of convenient link, as they would have had to install this in the first place. Equally, people who wouldn't normally do so won't install the plugin in the first place.

+ the holiday season is there for gift giving...most people won't gift a music album on a blank cd

My sister sends me one or two custom CDs every year with my Christmas goodies ;). I find these hand made CDs very special as it takes more of her time and thought.

Sounds like these are custom selections rather than a straight track for track copy of an album.

I could be reading your comment incorrectly though.

my comment wasn't meant to be too insightful. Just pointing out that "buying" isn't always better than "crafting". Sometimes its a straight rip of an album. Sometimes its a live show she attended during the year (some bands do allow legal live recordings). Sometimes its a mix.

Either way, I doubt this firefox tool hurts amazon sales. and if it does... ehhh... Bezos and Sony will live ;)

I disagree that people won't be deterred by a lack of a convenient link. Everyone has a threshold for how much work they're willing to put into something - this, in fact, is the driving principle behind Amazon's One Click.

This isn't costing Amazon a cent other than maybe some small bandwidth costs. Nobody who knows enough to install a Firefox plugin for a bittorrent site never found themselves buying a CD unaware that they could have gotten it for free.

It's always a matter of incentives and transaction costs. Now whoever uses this extension has a little bit more incentive and a little bit less cost to pirate. A locked door isn't enough deterrent to thieves that really want to steal from you, but they work well enough against the lazy ones.

Site's already down. The site has "The Ship was hit. We're offline." in <blink> tags.

A clever idea but the implementation is far from perfect.

On the product page for V, a novel by Thomas Pynchon, I got a torrent link for the fifth installment of the Saw horror movie series.

Hey brilliant plan. Now any time someone makes the claim that P2P isn't about not paying for copyrighted content they can point to this utility as counter-evidence.

"Amazon, the world’s largest online retailer, is under attack by online pirates. An add-on for the Firefox browser called ‘Pirates of the Amazon’ makes it possible to shop at the Amazon store but leave without paying a dime. Instead, on Amazon product pages the add-on integrates links to ‘free’ copies on The Pirate Bay."

Reply on news.ycombinator.com