Hacker News Reader

What I want next is for FireFox to do something to protect my cookies on disk. Chrome at least encrypts them using a key backed by the system keychain (although Chrome allows remote debugging from any other process, negating any benefits).

https://mango.pdf.zone/stealing-chrome-cookies-without-a-pas...

View on HN

IMHO this seems like pointless cat and mouse. If you don't have per-app sandboxing it will be fairly easy for any local application to scoop up both the database and encryption key. If you have sandboxing than relying on the systems full-disk encryption is sufficient. Adding a little obfuscation for the non-sandboxed case seems like trouble for very little improvement.

Maybe something that would be valuable is encryption with the password manager's master password. That way you would have to enter the password at browser startup.

The encryption Chrome uses isn't just some key on disk that can be scooped up. On macOS at least, it's stored in the secure enclave which only signed Chrome binaries can access.

Now all this is pointless due to Chrome allowing remote debugging, but Firefox could come along and do it right and it would actually be an increase in security. A random unsandboxed binary trying to access the key would be blocked by the kernel.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com