Hacker News Reader

Comment by frfl | Hacker News Reader

Slightly unrelated, but there is a 19 hour fan-edit of the Hobbit + Lord of the Rings -- i.e someone glued all 3 Hobbit movies and all 3 LotR movies into a 19 hour video.

View on HN

For starwars fans, there’s machete order: https://www.rodhilton.com/2011/11/11/the-star-wars-saga-sugg...

Hopefully that's 19 hours of LOTR with the 2-3 hours of the hobbit which was good.

No, it's uncut, all deleted scenes, extended version of all movies if I'm not mistaken. It's not a "remix" edit, the 19 hour one I'm referring to.

https://www.reddit.com/r/fanedits/comments/bo8how/middle_ear...

In the "2-3 hours of the hobbit which was good" are you including the animated versions as well? I'd be hard pressed to find 2-3 hours from the travesty that Jackson made

What didn't you like about it?

Different person, but just about everything. It simply wasn't enjoyable, at all. I'm just talking about the first hobbit, I have somehow managed to purge the memory of seeing the others from my memory.

I liked the LotR adaptations, though there were a few things I was pretty disappointed with.

But when it came to the Hobbit films it was a different story entirely, I saw the first and didn't love it. I saw the second and actively disliked it, so I figured I'd save myself the pain and haven't seen the third and I have no intention of watching it.

It's a shame that it was badly rushed, and split (needlessly) into three parts. But despite the close association it didn't ruin my enjoyment of the LotR films, which I rewatch every few years.

With all of the creative licensing that was taken with the content, I was really hoping that the Hobbit would have reduced the camp and gave it different tone to match the rest of the "universe". Instead, we got 20 minutes of dwarves throwing plates around and singing songs that does nothing except show examples of how the thinnest book was turned into 3 friggin' movies.

That's just one of the issues I had, but they don't get any nicer from there

Even in LOTR there are some wobbly sections outside the big story beats, when you re-watch it now. It's a good book to film adaptation of difficult material though.

I passed on The Hobbit.

You probably want the "Maple Edit" of the Hobbit (also known as "J.R.R. Tolkien's The Hobbit"). It is 247 minutes and is setup as a single film with intermissions.

Trailer:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=85gVFD7Dqwk

Info:

http://www.maple-films.com/jrr-tolkiens-the-hobbit/the-final...

I had no idea about this! Thank you for linking!

There are also fan-made "book edits" of LotR and the Hobbit that purge as much non-book material as possible while keeping th film coherent.

I believe that a 90 minutes cut of matrix 2+3 could be actually enjoyable.

"people copied our cool effects for Matrix 1, what if we make the action scenes so long and expensive no one would even bother to copy them because they all went home before they were over?"

The best way to watch that is almost certainly to come in on ~hour 10.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com