Hacker News Reader

Comment by tedunangst | Hacker News Reader

How about software support that's not download this Ubuntu distribution that's Ubuntu but not and only available from a site that may disappear tomorrow?

Or basic driver support? I have an orange pizzle and it has a software mouse cursor with mind blowing amounts of flicker. Hardware cursor was a solved problem 30 years, wtf is this???

View on HN

Do modern graphics cards still have hardware cursor support? I was pretty sure stuff like that went the way of sprite tables, once the hardware gets fast enough you don't need those dedicated 'trick' subunits any more, you just redraw the screen.

A lot of modern mobile GPUs have hardware plane support in the display controller. These kind of act like more versatile hardware cursors that can display any kind of data and also apply transformations to it. Afaik this is used for hardware cursors now.

I think that modern desktop GPUs do in fact still have hardware cursors; I recall digging into this before. The reason isn't speed or power usage, it's latency. The cursor position of a hardware cursor can be changed during the scan-out, which means that it can be significantly more up-to-date than the framebuffer itself. It's a pretty big deal for something feeling 'usable' and that's definitely why VMs and remote desktops will go through extra effort to make the cursor feel lower latency (remote desktops will outright fake it, while VMs will forward hardware cursor support through the guest to the host.) If you use an older computer with a CRT and no compositor, the lack of latency is marked; it makes it feel like things are happening before you even do them, and things feel "snappier" sometimes even when they're obviously a lot slower.

edit: Also, on Windows, you can notice the presence of the hardware cursor because Windows has an additional trick: it will switch to a software cursor when dragging windows, so that the window and the cursor stay synced up. However, since it doesn't perfectly sync the hardware cursor turning off with the software cursor frame being presented, you'll usually see a very subtle flicker when you first start dragging a window. I dunno if this still applies to fully-updated Windows, but it still applied last I checked, in Windows 10. (And once you notice this, boy, you never stop noticing it. It takes a second.. then it's hard to ever not see it again.)

> Also, on Windows, you can notice the presence of the hardware cursor because Windows has an additional trick

That's pretty interesting, I played with that and did notice it.

Also from googling if you set 'MouseTrails' to -1 in the registry it's a hack which disables the hardware cursor, not sure if that's still current.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com