Hacker News Reader

How is this even true? All members of a very vaguely and variably defined large group of humans have engaged in one specific behaviour, that to top it off is understood to bear responsibility very vaguely connected to the behaviour's laudable intent. ... If everything to you sounds like a dog whistle, then maybe you are a dog?

View on HN

What is vague or variable about it? Groups that explicitly represent themselves as Jewish have promoted progressive ideas such as multiculturalism, and are being criticized for the consequences of those policies.

May I suggest a refresher in basic set theory? "Groups that represent themselves as X" isn't equal to X.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com