Hacker News Reader

Comment by CoolGuySteve | Hacker News Reader

This just gave me infinite captcha challenges like some kind of practical joke.

This is a known issue with using 1.1.1.1 as a DNS

Maybe it would be better to report the issue the issue to archive.org because I can’t fix it…as much as I would like to.

Or maybe to your ISP?

Or VPN host if that’s involved?

That's quitter talk friend.

pushed up sleeves and starts editing code on archive.org

I have the image of someone opening up the browser's dev tools to write JS in the console tab. I'll just leave them to it!

VB6 all the way, baby!

archive.today isn’t associated with archive.org. It’s run by one guy who has a grudge against Cloudflare and gets angry when you use their DNS or anything that proxies your requests through Cloudflare, include iCloud Private Relay. You end up on a page that looks vaguely like a Cloudflare challenge, even though it’s his own doing and has nothing to do with Cloudflare.

If you’re on iOS, just open it in any browser other than Safari. Other browsers don’t get provided through iCloud Private Relay.

to be fair, I'd block visitors to my site if serving those visitors could result in legal action that would force me to take the site down. I hope I'd be a bit less juvenile about it, but it's not my site.

His gripe has to do with EDNS ECS (or lack thereof), not takedowns.

Nevertheless reporting the problem to archive.org would still be at least as effective as reporting the problem to me.

Anyway, for what it's worth it works fine on my iPhone using iOS Safari.

You would need iCloud Private Relay enabled to encounter the issue. Even then, you don’t get a say in which edge provider you get routed through: it may be Cloudflare, or it may be someone else (e.g., Akamai). It’s up to Apple.

Sorry for being confused, I didn’t realize I would need to make things complicated in order to give myself problems to complain about.

The trouble is that most people who have it enabled don't realize. If you're paying for iCloud+, it's likely enabled.

I'm not suggesting anyone should be complaining to you, though--I'm just explaining why some people encounter issues visiting archive.today links and providing them with a workaround (disable iCloud Private Relay).

Reply on news.ycombinator.com