You are one of the good people. Unfortunately, many will go the easy route: What it will do is that even more websites won't be available over here, and direct to a 451 ("Unavailable due to legal restrictions") error. This fragmentises the net.
Every single consumer protection has people show up on the side of the giant corporations. Usually a libertarian type with no clue how furious they would be if they got what they were asking for.
I use a lot of news aggregators, and never once got a link to a 451.
I think part of that is also that it's not foolproof to identify where a user is connecting from. Because I think legally, you can't use "but that user had an US IP address" as an excuse why you broke EU law against an EU citizen connecting from inside the EU.
Isn’t quite the argument you think it is.