Hacker News Reader

Comment by rsynnott | Hacker News Reader

I kind of assume that it’s because he’s desperate for attention, even negative attention, tbh. Note that every time talk about him dies down, he does something else stupid.

I wouldn’t be _amazed_ if the “woke mind virus” stuff is just because he’s found that the people who are into that tend to be easily led and into hero worship (I’m convinced that this is why transphobia got so popular with has-been British celebs a few years back; they’re rewarded with hero worship from this crowd). I would wonder how much of this he actually believes, or indeed if he has any beliefs beyond “people should talk about me all the time.”

View on HN

He (Musk) actually seems to care about humanity, and that baffles people.

He doesn't seem to care much about humanity to me.

In my opinion, he doesn't care about anything except being known as the guy who... For example:

He doesn't care about going to Mars. He cares about being known as the guy who went to mars

He doesn't care about transitioning the world away from fossil fuels. He cares about being known as the guy who transitioned the world away from fossil fuels

It just so happens that "being known as the guy who did something" generally correlates to the "thing actually being done". But for him that's just a nice side effect.

If you told him the world could have all of his goals with the caveat being nobody would know it was him who did it. I don't think he'd ever agree to that.

Again, just my opinion, but based on his public actions and antics this is what I currently believe about him.

From a behavioral psychology perspective we don’t necessarily discern between good quality and poor quality attention when considering attention as reinforcement. Eg behaviors that are reinforced by attention seek any attention regardless of the type of attention. I don’t care if you validate what I do, I care that you observe what I do. This is a core tenet of applied behavior analysis and why extinction for attention maintained behaviors requires removal of all attention, not just praise.

Thus “don’t feed the trolls” being the most sage wisdom in the history of the internet. However, we struggle to understand this core concept of the human condition and we don’t really cover it in any basic education. So as a result we have a society wherein it’s very easy for people who don’t give a shit about their image to rise in stature by being controversial instead of being correct or good.

As an aside this is something parents struggle with SO much in my work. We identify an attention maintained behavior. I educate on the above in more detail, function of behavior, extinction, etc. and then they almost always need to be corrected because they immediately scold the child, which is providing attention! Data analysis will show this has little impact on rates of behavior but planned ignoral will often have dramatic consequences if they can actually stay consistent with implementation. The problem for someone like Elon is that you will simply never get everyone to ignore him. This procedure generally only works with young children wherein you can get a good degree of stimulus control for that reason. Otherwise it’s the issue with telling a kid in middle school to ignore their bully. They might do it and they might do a perfect job but that bully will almost certainly continue to get reinforcement from other sources making the initial kids efforts essentially meaningless.

“Seems” is subjective, and its very easy for people to disagree with what one person thinks something “seems” like.

And that, as they say, baffles people.

Killing Californian high speed rail, calling a diver a pedophile, conducting inhumane primate experiments, and emphasizing radical political voices on Twitter are pivotal to the advancement of mankind, I take it?

Oh please. He objectively does not.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com