Comment by KronisLV | Hacker News Reader

Comment by KronisLV | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

> People love to hate on passwords but the reality is that for many circumstances (threat models) they are the best compromise. You can make them more than strong enough (take 32+ bytes out of /dev/random and encode however you like, nobody will ever brute force that in this universe) and various passwords managers solve the problem of re-use (never reuse a password).

> And it comes with the benefit that you control how it is stored and can apply as much redundancy as you want to feel comfortable.

Honestly, I agree!

I used KeePass back in the day (https://keepass.info/) but now use KeePassXC (https://keepassxc.org/) and it's really nice - I don't know any of my passwords because they're all randomly generated and are pretty secure, in addition to them being unique for every account. The only one I have to remember is my main password for decrypting the safe, which I also wrote down and entrusted to someone close to me due to its complexity.

It honestly works great, software to interact with the password safe is on every platform where I need it to be, in addition to it being super easy to reason about storage, because it's basically just a file - that I can then put on self-hosted Nextcloud, or another solution like that, or USB sticks or burn to CDs for all I care.

Maybe I should also migrate all of my TOTP stuff over to it and look into good Android apps at some point, then I wouldn't quite need Google Authenticator or FreeOTP anymore, either.

I tried a few different android apps a few years ago and since then I'm a happy user of Keepass2Android.

You're gonna have a problem when you're on a trip abroad and lose your phone. Your only recourse is to go to the local internet cafe and log on to your email so you can send a message for help. Except you can't, because you dont know your password...

> You're gonna have a problem when you're on a trip abroad and lose your phone.

There's also the possibility of bringing my netbook with me, which also could have a Nextcloud client setup (or Syncthing, or some cloud based option), same as every other device that I own, which would have the last offline backup of the file even if the server itself would blink out of existence.

Honestly a bigger problem without my phone would be the fact that I basically couldn't pay for things all that well when using a card, because of a redirect to my bank when making a purchase online (to confirm it), which then makes me use https://www.smart-id.com/ with a code to confirm it. That's kind of a problem because it's not TOTP but rather it's bound to the device.

I can work around the password safe issue with an SD card that has the database on it, or a USB stick as well, but that wouldn't work for the app, so in the modern day I'd basically need to have two phones, the same way someone might have two sets of keys to their apartment or something. Kind of crazy when you think about it. And I'd also need a smart card reader to even register a new account in most cases, in combination with my government issued ID card.

Solution: use a memorable password for one of your cloud services. One that does not require 2FA. Keep a copy of password db there.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com