SpaceX slams FAA report on falling space debris danger | Hacker News Reader

SpaceX slams FAA report on falling space debris danger

spacenews.com

4 pointsbelter4 comments

Definitely some strange assumptions by the FAA. Simulations by both NASA and SpaceX (as well as observations of over 300 Starlink re-entries) indicate Starlink sats burn up completely. Yet FAA assigns each Starlink satellite a ~9 square meter injury/fatality zone on the ground.

To be precise, the FAA makes no such assumptions, instead they directly quote the results of an independant Aerospace Corporation Technical Report (included as an annexure to the FAA submission)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Aerospace_Corporation

https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/Report_to_Congress_R...

These are based on 1970s VAST studies on reentry debris survivability which are applied to the the SpaceX satellite tonnages and upper stages of launch vehicles.

The FAA explicitly qualifies this with:

    If SpaceX is correct in reporting zero surviving debris, as SpaceX reports in FCC filings, and Starlink is a fully-demisable spacecraft, the rise in reentry risk is minimal over the current risk.

The question the FAA poses is "IF ... as SpaceX reports ..." and they suggest that is a area worth careful scrutiny.

By 2035 SpaceX will almost certainly be recovering the upper stage of Starship as well.

Heck maybe they’ll even be recovering or refueling Starlink satellites if launch cost of Starship makes that viable.

Says space junk purveyor s.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com