Hacker News Reader

The difference being pulp is ripe fruit in a fruit juice you're drinking and seeds/leaves/dirt are not edible for us in the first place. I seriously don't get it—if you don't like fruit why drink fruit juice. Plenty of "fruit flavored" ones (I'm partial to Aranciata Rossa Pellegrino)

The seeds and leaves are edible. They just don't taste good (and aren't juice).

>I seriously don't get it—if you don't like fruit why drink fruit juice

So you include the seeds, rind, and pith in your juices, right? Or are you just a pretend fruit liker as well?

"Pulp isn't juice"

True, but a juice can contain pulp, and that's what they're asking. You want the juice with or without pulp.

Juice can contain pulp like salad can contain dirt.

And cream is not coffee but here we are