Comment by kumarvvr | Hacker News Reader

Comment by kumarvvr | Hacker News Reader

Yeah, this is not the western idea of Pickle.

These are long lasting, chilli powder filled, Mustard powder based goodness, that is tasty throughout the year, filling and an absolute delight.

There are so many fond memories of eating mango pickle with steaming hot rice, in the hot summers in my home.

In every Indian Home (at least in the south that I know about), you will find at least a couple of these pickles stocked all the time. Mango, Tomato, Tamarind are very famous.

Also, many westerners don't know about Powder delicacies, meant to be eaten with rice, dosas, idly, etc. I personally know atleast a dozen types of these powders.

https://cookingfromheart.com/kandi-podi-andhra-special-parup...

These are nutritious and absolutely delicious.

Some hot rice with a pickle and a powder, capped off with curd rice is a wholesome meal when there is no time or you are too tired.

A list of recipes

https://www.vegrecipesofindia.com/mango-pickle-recipe-andhra...

https://cookingfromheart.com/magaya-pachadi/

https://www.gayatrivantillu.com/recipes-2/chutneys-and-aacha...

https://www.gayatrivantillu.com/recipes-2/chutneys-and-aacha...

https://www.indianhealthyrecipes.com/andhra-tomato-pickle-ni...

> Yeah, this is not the western idea of Pickle.

> These are long lasting, chilli powder filled, Mustard powder based goodness, that is tasty throughout the year, filling and an absolute delight.

Achar right? 'Pickle' is exactly what I'd (white British) call it, and vice versa not be surprised when it was what I was given.

Maybe you're thinking of American 'dill pickle' (where the pickle stands for 'with pickled cucumber') but that's at best just one type, and it's only 'American idea' (rather than 'western') that the preserved cucumber itself is to be termed 'a pickle'.

It is true that most non-Indian/inspired pickles I can think of are whole (or large pieces of) vegetables in vinegar and not a lot else, which looks different I suppose but it's the same preservation method. Nimbu achar 'lime pickle' especially is about as common as mango aam ki chutney in Indian restaurants/takeaways in the UK.

A more significant difference, if you insist, between Indian and 'western' pickle would be the presence of oil. But pickle is the right term, and achar is not a stranger to our plates.

As a bit of a pickle enthusiast, I must object to the idea that it is "vegetables in vinegar and not a lot else".

I was looking at making various Japanese pickles last year and rice bran with miso is a very common dry pickling bed; salt pickles are far more common than vinegar pickles (the recipe book I looked at had about ¼ of its pickles with some sort of vinegar, usually a rice vinegar).

Even vinegar-based Western pickles are far more interesting than "just vinegar", because most pickles have herbs and spices (pickled dill cucumbers have dill, garlic, and often mustard seed or coriander, sometimes chilli flakes). Also fairly common in Western pickles are wine pickles (not for cucumbers; sometimes used to finish the aging of sauerkraut) or salt pickles (preserved lemon, most sauerkrauts, the better pickled dill cucumbers).

And then you get the interesting pickles like Branston Pickle (more accurately called a chutney made with pickled vegetables, but…).

I also buy quite a few oil-pickled products from Italy; I suspect that many Mediterranean cultures use oil pickling over vinegar pickling. (Although the production methods for most of these would start with brining — salt pickling — they would be dried and the curing would be finished in the oil that they ship in.)

> As a bit of a pickle enthusiast, I must object to the idea that it is "vegetables in vinegar and not a lot else". I was looking at making various Japanese pickles [...]

To be clear I said 'most' and I meant only to be talking about what's prevalent in the UK, but I appreciate that wasn't clear in that paragraph (I only said 'non-Indian/inspired').

But anyway it was only to pander to 'sure you [the other commenter] might be thinking a pickle means a different looking thing', when my whole point was yes I agree it's a pickle, I'm absolutely not saying a pickle needs to be only vinegar and vegetable, or very liquidy, or really anything more strict than just that it be anaerobically fermented. (I'd far sooner/do exclude 'quick pickle', 'fridge pickle', et al. than achar!)

Since you mention 'oil-pickled products from Italy', a Delia-inspired favourite of mine is what she calls 'gardeners pickle' (pickles giardiniere) - the gist is roughly chopped vegetables (I think she includes mushrooms, fennel, onions, courgettes, aubergine, peppers, and tomato) in oil, vinegar, and salt. My frequently make it with just courgette and onion, perhaps plus cherry tomato - unfortunate bulk, with a piercing to allow the vinegar to penetrate they really are delicious! I eat it mostly on fresh bread with vintage cheddar (that's very mature, salty, I'm not sure it's available like that in the US - cheddar on the whole is not the same, and 'sharp' is not it) but it's also excellent as an addition to gazpacho - it's basically the same thing unblended after all.

It's true that Americans call pickled cucumbers "pickles", they are far and away the most common kind, but we're aware of what pickling is, and have pickled eggs, pickled radish, pickled beets, and while we don't refer to sauerkraut as pickled cabbage (we call it, well, sauerkraut), we do know that's what it is.

We don't eat as much Branston pickle as Brits do, but it's available in most supermarkets.

I didn't mean to imply you don't, more that I'm aware of that ('a pickle') and can't speak with much certainty about what else is available.

My point was only supposed to be that I can't see what's wrong with 'pickle' as a translation. I don't think any Indian would hesitate to call picallili an achar at a glance (on tasting it they might find it unexpectedly mild, but certainly you can have mild achars).

Fair enough, when buying achar at an Indian grocery in the States, it's a crap shoot whether they'll call it e.g. "Mango achar" or "Mango pickle". Oil pickling isn't a part of traditional American food, granted, but pickle is a translation that gets used.

Lol "famous"? Sorry I don't think a pickle can be famous but ya know different strokes.

Famous within India at least. There's a billion-plus people there.

Famous in the sense that a Twinkie is "famous" in the US.

Try to ban Mango Pickle in India, there would be riots on the streets !

famous | ˈfeɪməs | adjective 1 known about by many people: a famous star | the country is famous for its natural beauty. 2 informal excellent: Galway stormed to a famous victory.

Various types of pickles are in fact "famous":

- Mango pickle (not my favourite Indian pickle; right now that would be garlic pickle and my standby is lime pickle)

- New York deli half-sour pickled cucumbers (not a vinegar pickle, but a fermented pickle).

- Umeboshi (salt-pickled Japanese plums)

- Kimchi (Korean fermented cabbage and vegetables)

- Kapusta / Sauerkraut (Ukrainian and German fermented/pickled cabbage, respectively)

There are others, but the point has been made. When you consider that "famous" is often used to mean "beloved", your ignorance is showing.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com