Hacker News Reader

Comment by thunderbird120 | Hacker News Reader

There are few air bases but many sections of highway which are long and straight enough to take off from. Targeting all of them with expensive precision munitions is totally impractical.

View on HN

How clean does a runway have to be for an F-35 to take-off from it? I remember a lot of internet grief over the idea of shipping American fighters to Ukraine, on the grounds that the F-16 and other American fighters were designed only for pristine runways. Low air intakes of the sort Americans favor would ingest debris that would damage the engines, so runways have to be absolutely clear. The MiG-29, on the other hand, has auxiliary air intakes above the wing for taking off on a poorly maintained airstrip. So, does the F-35 need specially cleaned highways?

FOD is something to avoid when operating aircraft, everywhere. Meaning clean is clean enough, and if it isn't an emergency landing strips are prepared (basic maintenance, personal facilities, fuel...)

Regarding Ukraine, if it is internet grief, it is fair to assume it is wrong.

And besides, F-16s have operated from Ukrainian airbases before the war in joint exercises. It's not as if US aircraft are fragile snowflakes.

Well, Finland has been landing and taking off F-18s on these road bases for almost 30 years now.

I thought this was a VTOL aircraft so runway length should not be such an issue.

The F-35A variant doesn't do VTOL.

The article references the F-35A which is the conventional take-off/landing variant whereas the VTOL variant is the F-35B.

The article references the F-35A which is a conventional take off and landing aircraft (CTOL). The F-35B is the short take off and vertical landing (STOVL) variant. The F-35B belongs to the marines is capable of using extremely short and improvised runways and this has been part of its operational concept for quite a while[1]. For an expeditionary force that kind of thing is important.

The F-35A is a bit different in that its a normal air force fighter. This is just proving that if push comes to shove it can be operated out of improvised bases.

[1]https://www.thedrive.com/the-war-zone/f-35b-just-touched-dow...

VTOL takeoff usually reduces payload vs a more normal takeoff.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com