I commend you for making this effort! It is such an easy thing to do and so worth it. Is there any specific schema or method behind it?
If I see the reminder I try to call/text that person when I have some down time. I tick the box when done, or if I think I've seen talked to them organically recently enough.
I'd be cool if it could somehow tell from my call/whatsapp log/calendar how long it's actually been, but it being a fuzzy is a feature too.
And as you say, definitely worth it.