Hacker News Reader

Comment by zmj | Hacker News Reader

Got your experimental programming language:

> Vitess - a new project released by YouTube, written in Go, it’s a frontend to MySQL. It does a lot of optimization on the fly, it rewrites queries and acts as a proxy. Currently it serves every YouTube database request. It’s RPC based.

View on HN

Ah yes, but it's using a ~30 year old technology (RPC).

Is RPC an actual technology? I thought it was more of a protocol design pattern.

man callrpc

When Youtube refers to Vitess as being RPC-based, they are not referring to Sun RPC (callrpc), but rather to the generic design pattern of exposing service calls over the network. In particular, Vitess makes services callable [-] using either BSON or JSON serialisation over HTTP CONNECT calls.

[-] http://code.google.com/p/vitess/source/browse/go/rpcwrap/

Remote Procedure Call is a design paradigm for synchronous call-and-response network communication. The Sun RPC protocol is an actual technology defined in RFC1057: http://www.ietf.org/rfc/rfc1057.txt

It's not insane, though not terribly relevant in the modern world. The only common technology still using it is NFS.

If you look at the original RPC work by Bruce Nelson [1], it's pretty clear that there's no strict definition of it. I think most would argue that SOAP would be included, which is still pretty common.

1: http://nd.edu/~dthain/courses/cse598z/fall2004/papers/birrel...

No, that's the ambiguity I was addressing. RPC means two things. The protocol is used, for the most part, only by NFS. The concept is pervasive.

That's ONC RPC. Not the only implementation. XDR is still used in places, though you're right that it isn't widely used.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com