Hacker News Reader

Comment by fallingknife | Hacker News Reader

What do I care about inequality? If someone invents some new tech and makes a trillion dollars how am I worse off?

The newly-minted trillionaire could use their wealth to monopolize positional goods: social status, housing, politicians' attention. This could worsen your standard of living if you compete with them for the same positional goods.

You define "standard of living" positionally, which is not how it is usually defined, but does make a lot of sense given the prevalence of envy. By that definition, yes, inequality does absolutely worsen standard of living. Points for being honest about your motivations, unlike every other person who rails against inequality.

Because children can't eat correct, even in the western countries (and while US and UK are the worst offenders, this isn't limited to them).

That's also why I'm quite cross with the 'you should have children' crowd. No. Please don't. I've heard of a 14 yo girl prostitute herself in the toilets to guys her age (from her class even). A quick BJ for two meals. And I've seen her cry after that. Imagine the reputation she had in her highschool (this was circa 2010, so social networks already existed but no smartphone in the area).

If we cannot take care of our children half-decently, everybody, even those with atrophic empathy, should care.

The fact that we do not is a stain on humanity.

In your hypothetical scenario where a trillion dollars spring into being without any other consequences: you’re not.

If you want to sprinkle some consequences into the scenario, how about you lose your job, and the supply of positions for said job decreases to a third.

Do you like centralized power? Would you like to live in a dictatorship? Because that's what inequality taken to the extreme is. So unless you do like those things, you should care about inequality.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com