Hacker News Reader

Comment by ChumpGPT | Hacker News Reader

This is what communism brought for those who lived under it. After 50 years people had to line up to get their food. Just look around the world and see what people who live under that system reap, poverty and slavery. Thank God Poland freed itself from that evil imposed on it by Russia who was the main driver of that garbage. Can you believe Russia still glorifies it and celebrates it's hero's Lenin and Stalin, insane.....

View on HN

Don't worry, random internet commenters have assured me that it's only because literally every country who tried communism didn't do it correctly.

If we try again, it'll definitely lead to a utopia.

Well these ration tickets are the ultimate stage of a planned economy; the purest communist dream.

You would be very surprised how many 60+ year olds that lived through soviet occupation would agree with that statement.

It's bizarre..

The same way that North Korean people may not want to be freed.

They are used to some system, where others are responsible and deciding of their life.

And this brings a lot of psychological comfort, and simplicity (no choice = it's easy to choose).

It's psychologically much easier to have others deciding, and to complain about the result, than having to take ownership and responsibility for your life and your choices.

If you don't have a choice, you can't do a wrong choice.

That makes sense

Yes + guaranteed work and housing is a clear advantage :) (or "ice cream was tastier")

> Can you believe Russia still glorifies it

You don't have to look to Russia to find people glorifying Socialism and Communism as there are plenty of those in western countries to be had, especially in academia and other educational institutions. That is where the late-60s radicals went for the most part and they have left their marks to the detriment of (nearly) all.

Yes, but the Russians actually celebrate nationally like China, North Korea, etc.

Russia has gone through the stages of a socialist/communist revolution like those other countries and as such has had its culture infused with the symbolism and mannerism of the ideology. Russians know what it leads to but they also remember what happened to those who opposed the state so they lay low and try to watch out for themselves and their own. The wannabe-revolutionaries at e.g. American educational institutions (from university to K-12) should know better but wilfully ignore the warnings history - or 'herstory' for the most radical among them - has given them about the ideology they push. To me the latter are more dangerous than the former because they can do more damage to us in 'the western world' - what propagandistically used to be called 'the free world' [1]. They know they are abusing their positions to turn their pupils into young activists instead of teaching them the necessary skills needed for self-fulfilment. The know they are using them as pawns instead of giving them the tools they need to get along in society but they do so because they want to bring about their utopia and are convinced that can only happen once current society has been brought to its knees - they follow Paulo Freire’s “Pedagogy of the Oppressed” to the letter even though it has failed miserably everywhere it has been tried but this time it will work, surely, they never tried for real.

[1] ...where it is worth remembering that the west was more free compared to the Soviet block even if it was (and increasingly is) far from 'free' in an objective sense.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com